Reward for Value
Startup advisors bring valuable insights, industry expertise, and connections that can accelerate growth, help avoid common pitfalls, and provide strategic guidance. Advisors may support areas such as product development, fundraising, marketing strategies, and customer acquisition. The nature and depth of their engagement will largely depend on the startup’s specific needs.
Importance of Compensation
Advisors typically have deep experience and provide high-level guidance to startups. Although some may offer assistance pro bono, most require compensation, particularly if they are expected to dedicate significant time and resources. Compensation acts as an incentive for advisors to commit and stay invested in the startup’s success. It also ensures that both parties are aligned on the startup’s objectives.
Cash vs. Equity Compensation
Cash compensation is less common for startup advisors, especially for early-stage ventures that are usually low on liquidity. Offering equity is a more popular alternative, aligning the advisor’s interest with the long-term success of the company. Equity-based compensation not only motivates advisors to contribute to the company’s growth but also allows cash-strapped startups to access top-tier expertise without the need for immediate monetary payment.
Equity Compensation Models
Equity is often awarded in the form of stock options or restricted shares, subject to a vesting schedule. A common practice is a two-year vesting period with a three-month cliff, meaning the advisor must serve the company for at least three months before earning any shares. This ensures that advisors remain committed for the long term and allows startups to adjust if the relationship does not work out as planned.
Several factors determine how much equity should be offered, including:
Advisor’s Contribution
Advisors who are deeply involved in the company’s operations, such as those assisting with product development or helping secure funding, generally receive a higher equity percentage.
Company Stage
Early-stage startups typically offer more equity since they have lower cash reserves, whereas more established companies may compensate advisors with a smaller equity share or a mix of cash and equity.
Time Commitment
The amount of time an advisor spends on the startup’s activities plays a significant role in determining compensation. For instance, advisors who are expected to contribute regularly (e.g., attending meetings, helping with key decisions) may receive a larger equity stake compared to those who provide more occasional input.
Calculating Equity Compensation
There are several methods to determine the appropriate equity compensation for advisors. One common approach is based on the company’s valuation and the advisor’s expected contribution in terms of time and expertise. For example, a startup valued at £5 million might offer an advisor with an hourly rate of £200 for 50 hours of work per year, resulting in an equity share proportional to the total value contributed.
Another popular approach is the “Founder/Advisor Standard Template” (FAST) agreement. This method outlines different levels of company maturity (idea, startup, and growth) and advisor involvement (standard, strategic, and expert) to calculate appropriate equity shares. For example, an expert-level advisor providing strategic input during a startup’s early growth phase might receive around 0.8% equity.
How Much Equity to Offer
Generally, equity compensation for advisors ranges between 0.25% to 2%, depending on the factors mentioned above. High-value advisors who contribute significantly to the company’s trajectory may receive higher equity stakes, while those who play more minor roles typically receive less. For instance, an advisor helping with a critical product pivot or key customer acquisition might receive up to 2%, whereas those offering periodic advice on non-core issues might receive closer to 0.25%.
Best Practices for Structuring Advisor Agreements
When formalising the relationship with an advisor, it is essential to draft a well-defined agreement. This agreement should detail the advisor’s responsibilities, expected time commitment, confidentiality clauses, and compensation structure. Setting clear expectations will ensure that both the advisor and the startup understand their roles and commitments.
Additionally, it is a good idea to regularly reassess the relationship, ensuring that the advisor remains relevant to the company’s evolving needs. A periodic review (e.g., every six months) allows for adjustments to the advisory board or compensation terms as the company grows and its priorities change.
Cash Compensation
While less common, some startups opt for cash payments, particularly when the advisor’s role is more transactional or short-term. Cash compensation might be appropriate when the advisor is performing a specific task (e.g., helping with a one-off fundraising round). In such cases, compensation is typically a fixed fee or an hourly rate.
However, it’s worth noting that many advisors prefer equity over cash, as it aligns their success with the company’s growth. Startups that offer cash payments should be prepared to provide competitive rates to attract top talent.
Combining Cash and Equity
In some cases, startups offer a hybrid model that includes both cash and equity. This approach is suitable for later-stage companies with more financial flexibility but who still want to provide an equity incentive. For example, an advisor might receive a small cash payment for regular monthly meetings and equity for more strategic, long-term contributions.
Evaluating Advisor Contributions
To ensure the success of the advisor-startup relationship, it’s important to evaluate the advisor’s contributions periodically. This helps the startup determine whether the advisor is adding value and if the compensation arrangement remains fair. If an advisor is not meeting expectations, the startup has the opportunity to adjust the equity vesting schedule or replace the advisor with someone more aligned with its needs.
Conclusion
Compensating startup advisors effectively is key to fostering a productive and long-term relationship. Whether offering equity, cash, or a combination of both, it’s important to tailor the compensation package to the advisor’s contributions and the startup’s financial situation. By establishing clear agreements and regularly reassessing the relationship, startups can ensure they receive the guidance they need to succeed while keeping their advisors motivated and invested in the company’s success.
Startups must also be mindful of their evolving needs, as advisors who are a good fit at the beginning may not necessarily remain so as the company scales. Therefore, maintaining flexibility and openness to change is crucial for the sustainability of these relationships.
Need some help with your business? Reach out here.